The Lucky Ones

March 1, 2020

Gr 7 Up-May is a survivor of the school shooting where her twin brother, Jordan, and some friends died. But she doesn't feel like a survivor. She feels angry and guilty for what happened in the band room that day. She survived by staying in the closet, but that did not prevent her from hearing, and then seeing, everything that happened. Zach is angry, too. His mother can't see how being the lawyer of the school shooter is making his and his sister's lives unbearable. When someone paints epithets on their garage, he feels too hopeless to tell his mother how her decisions are affecting them. But when May and Zach meet, something magical happens for both of them. Can either teen truly move on with the other, especially when neither is being exactly truthful with themselves or one another? May, Zach, their families, and friends are all complex and intriguing characters that readers will immediately connect with and want to see succeed. VERDICT This heartbreaking and touching story of grief and loss, as well as hope and forgiveness, will resonate with readers who deal with this fear and reality on a daily basis.-Traci Glass, Nashville Public Library

Copyright 2020 School Library Journal, LLC Used with permission.

March 9, 2020
In this intense, affecting debut, May McGintee is “one of the lucky ones,” though she feels anything but. Back in school for junior year, May is consumed by survivor’s guilt: 11 months ago, she hid in a closet as her genius twin brother Jordan, favorite teacher, and five classmates were shot and killed during band practice. Following an ineffectual stint of homeschooling after she was kicked out of school for fighting, this is likely May’s last chance to graduate with her peers. Angry, isolated, and regretting the distance between Jordan and her when he died, with parents who are detached themselves, May is a mess. So is classmate Zach Teller: his mother is the shooter’s lawyer, which means he’s a social pariah whose house keeps getting vandalized. When Zach and May meet, they form a real connection, strong enough that it survives May’s fury upon learning Zach’s identity. Lawson does a good job at conveying how out of control May feels alongside her friends’ continued love for her, and though parts of the plot feel predictable, the book credibly depicts the terror of “the frightening places and the daily places” being “one and same,” building to a tentatively hopeful ending that feels earned. Ages 14–up.

April 1, 2020
Grades 9-12 Tragically relevant and with a nuanced perspective on grief and being a survivor, Lawson's debut introduces readers to high-school-shooting survivor and bereaved sister May and the son of the lawyer defending the school shooter, Zach. When the two encounter each other as new classmates, there's an instant spark?but their previous connection could tear them apart before they have a chance to begin. Meanwhile, May's unresolved grief and guilt threatens to inflict permanent damage on her, and Zach must find a way to stand up to or forgive his mother. Lawson writes in alternating perspectives, creating distinct voices in this powerful story of what remains after a violent tragedy. With a strong depiction of sibling loss, in particular, The Lucky Ones portrays grief as multifaceted and complicated. The well-rounded characters have complex motivations and emotions, while Lawson is careful never to talk down to teens and adds an unexpected but sensitively-handled, blossoming romance. This is an excellent pick for fans of Jennifer Brown's Hate List (2009) and Jenny Hubbard's And We Stay (2014).(Reprinted with permission of Booklist, copyright 2020, American Library Association.)

Starred review from February 1, 2020
Two teens find each other (and themselves) with a little help from their friends in this story of survival, perseverance, and hope. In alternating first-person narration, two familiar character types--loose-cannon May McGintee and awkward try-hard Zach Teller--are quickly defamiliarized. May is the sole survivor of a massacre that robbed her twin brother, favorite teacher, and five peers of their lives. She's struggled with survivor's guilt and PTSD ever since, and her best friend, Lucy, is the only person who keeps her going. Zach has been taking care of his family, especially younger sister Gwen, since his father fell into a deep depression five years ago. When his attorney mother defends the shooter, almost everybody he knows--except his best friend, Conor--abandons him. When Lucy auditions for Conor's band, May and Zach meet cute. As May begins putting herself back together, Zach learns what being there truly entails. Lawson's extraordinary knack for navigating typical teenage-rule predicaments--parent problems, friend frustration, budding desire--and the most searing circumstances--loss, terror, rage, fault--keeps the plot at a boil. Though shaped like a romance, Lawson's remarkable debut celebrates love's many forms, from friends who refuse to be pushed away to families slowly closing years of distance. Lucy is Haitian; Conor, Zach, and May are white. Wildly ambitious and wholly empathetic, devastatingly raw, and impossibly gentle; a must-read in this moment. (author's note, resources) (Fiction. 14-18)

COPYRIGHT(2020) Kirkus Reviews, ALL RIGHTS RESERVED.